Our office is conveniently located off of State Road 109 and next to Citizen’s Bank. Doctors Mary Beth Sheehan and Anne Neitzke and their team want to help you achieve and maintain a beautiful, healthy smile. We serve patients of all ages and always welcome new patients into our practice.
New patients can now schedule online! If you're already a patient, please call your practice directly to schedule. You'll find a list of insurances we currently accept on our payment options page. If you do not see your insurance listed, please contact our patient services team at (888) 403-0731 so we can check for a nearby practice that may accept your plan. Please note that any patient portion of payment is due at the time of service.
Schedule an Appointment
Please click below to use our scheduling portal to reserve your new patient or emergency appointment.
- For a list of insurances we currently accept along with additional payment options, please click here.
- If you do not see your insurance listed, please call our patient services team at (888) 403-0731.
- If you have a dental emergency and do not see an appointment available when you need it, please call the practice directly at (765) 345-7780 to speak with a team member.
You are about to leave our site
You will now be redirected to a secure link to complete your patient forms for the Knightstown office.
HoursMon: 8am - 5pm
Tue: 8am - 5pm
Wed: 8am - 7pm
Thu: 8am - 5pm
Fri: 8am - 4:30pm
Dr. Mary Beth Sheehan
Dr. Mary Beth Sheehan graduated from Ball State University in 1989. She attended Indiana School of Dentistry and graduated in 1992. She is a member of the American Dental Association and the Indiana Dental Association. She has been seeing patients at Knightstown Gentle Dentist since 1995.
Dr. Sheehan continues to enjoy the technical aspect of performing dentistry. New products and innovations have made dentistry so much better for the dentist AND the patient. Her most enjoyable part of her practice is the patients. Seeing once nervous patients continue to come in faithfully for check ups and treatment lets her know she has truly made a difference. Some of her first young patients now have spouses and children that come to see her as well.
Dr. Sheehan has been married to Dr. Jeff Stahly for 22 years. They have 3 children- Audrey, Libby and David. She watches the Colts, the Pacers, IU and Butler basketball. She has the most fun when she gets together with friends and family.
Dr. Anne Neitzke
Dr. Anne Neitzke ( pronounced, “Night-Ski”) , grew up in Elkhart, Indiana. She graduated from Elkhart Central High School in 1986. She obtained her Bachelor of Science degree in Business from Miami University in Oxford, Ohio. Anne graduated from Indiana University School of Dentistry in 1996.
Anne and her husband, Robert, whom she met in high school, reside in Indianapolis. He works for Cummins Engine Company in Columbus, Indiana. Robert’s job has taken him to many countries worldwide. They have two children, Max and Lola. Anne has worked at Knightstown Gentle Dentist since 2003. Anne’s hobbies include spending time with family and friends, reading, traveling, and playing with her two cherished cockapoo puppies, Pickles and Juneau.
One of the many reasons Dr. Anne chose dentistry as a profession is that she had a grandfather who was, and brother who is a dentist. She saw how much they enjoyed the profession, and encouraged her to pursue the same career. She is grateful for the kind dentists she had over the years who coached her through the fears of her own dental appointments as a child. Dr Anne enjoys helping others get through their dental fears, as well. She likes to really get to know her patients of all ages and help them achieve healthy teeth and beautiful smiles. She has always been very happy with her choice in careers.
Dr. John Wiles
Dr. John Wiles attended Ball State University, where he earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in English literature before pursuing his dental degree at the Indiana University School of Dentistry. Prior to joining Gentle Dentist, Dr. Wiles served patients in the Rushville, Indiana, area for 22 years. Dr. Wiles lives in Knightstown with his wife of 25 years, Jan, and their bull mastiff, Gracie. They have three sons: Caleb, Owen and Henry. In his free time, he enjoys fishing, reading, hunting and spending time with family.
Learn more about how we are keeping our team members and patients safe.